Librarian as Teacher and Learner
As Sara Johns says, "It's time to make some noise." (p2) If we as librarians are to succeed in proving that we are more than just the one who dust the books, we are going to have to make that noise. We are teachers and we do know the Common Core skills that our students are to complete and we do know how to collaborate with our teachers to teach these skills. We do know how to help calm their nerves as they worry about meeting all the requirements for the Common Core Standards. We are teachers. We teach skills, technology, research and how to not plagiarize. We teach our students how to work individually and to cooperate with each other in groups. We encourage our students to be creative and to use our technology to prove their ability to do so. We teach. We are needed and we are worth our school districts money. It was a sad thing to read about the teachers in Valenza's article. I do know if I could fight and defend over and over my position and the need for me as they have had to do. Valenza worries that she may not have "made it perfectly clear that we teach and what we teach." I too worry about that in my job, have I done everything I can to insure that my superiors see the need for me? Do they know what I do as their Librarian? I am the only one who can answer that question. I teach. I need that peace of mind that I have done everything within my power to show that I teach. As the librarian I have to make sure that technology, space, and collaboration are all within my library. Staff and students alike have to be informed of what you have available for them and that you are there to guide them and help in all manners. I like the poster that Valenza made that listed what she did. (p4) That is not a bad idea for all librarians.
In our text "Empowering Learners" we read that we must "evolve from a 20th Century industrial model to a dynamic, fluid environment that promotes high-order thinking." As our libraries become the learning commons we will be moving forward as a fluid environment. We will have provided the open concept of working together in a space that is conductive to learning. We will have provided a space that is virtual as well as physical. One of the actions that is listed is for the media specialist to "create an environment of mutual respect and collaboration."(p32) That is what our libraries today are moving toward in a learning commons and that is what has been accomplished in the video that we viewed on you tube. "CHHS Learning Commons Part 2." That librarian was valued by her principal and staff and students alike. She had worked to make the Learning Commons a space for all to create and learn and use the technology that is readily available to students today and she was successful and I am so glad to see that there is hope for us all if we just push ourselves out there and prove that we do teach and that we are as valuable to our school community. As a manager of the library/learning commons we are the one who brings forward the supplies and provides for the needs of our students and staff. We are the collector, the gardener of weeding, the jobber of all instructional materials in our library. We have purchased, begged, and spent our own monies to insure that everything is there for our 21st Century Learner. We are teachers. Woolls teaches us in chapter 8 how to manage our libraries. From records to weeding we learn that the librarian is the teacher, the lawyer, the collector, the gardener, the purchaser and the house keeper. We wear many hats. We learned that from parents to law enforcement agents are among those we must contend with on top of our teaching duties. I have questions concerning our legal jobs from reading this chapter and will post them at the end of my paper. Woolls teaches of our technology decisions that we will make throughout our careers and that we must make "careful explanation" of everything we do. (p130) Just as we have learned to advocate for our libraries within this class; we must do the same to "implement new technology" for our libraries. In chapter 10 we begin the chapter with the "four components of school library media programs," they are "personnel, materials, equipment and facility." Again we learn that the librarian is responsible for it all. It is beyond me how so many people today can stand up and say that the librarian is not needed. We attend classes to better ourselves in our jobs. To ensure that our students are being taught by the best and that we learn about the very newest of everything just to be able to present it to our staff and students. We learn in the Catone article that education is presented to us online as well as in traditional classroom settings and that more and more the online courses are being utilized by many non traditional students as well as our younger students. The article says that test scores seem to be better from a student who takes courses online but the article could not say why. Canton also gives a "framework for online learning" (p2) that from my prospective is no different than classroom attendance learning, we all must learn the same thing, no matter where we sit and the article backs up my opinion on page three. The article states that how we "apply" what we learn is what is most important. We will need to "adapt" (p3) ourselves to use the "new tools and methods" learned but that too is something all teachers already have learned. The point is that online courses will be used to teach the teacher and "online learning is an adequate stand-in" (p4) for the physical professor but not a replacement all together.
Important questions for you to help me with:-thoughts from Woolls chapter 8.
1) If a parent comes into the library and tells you that she/he does not want their child to read this book or that subject or anything from a certain author or two; what do you say? Do you agree and block the child or do you inform the parent that all books in your library are age appropriate for their child or what? This is not clear in the chapter we read.
2) If the law officer comes in and subpoena's your records of a teacher or student; do you quickly hand them over or do you call in your superintendent? Our chapter was confusing to me on this matter.
3) Do you feel that online learning is less of an education than regular classroom learning or more?
4) Do you have a selection policy in your library for all materials?
Jeannie,
ReplyDeleteGreat summary and awesome questions!!! I agree with you that there was a lot of information to our reading/viewing this week, and I probably could have written much more if I wasn't so sick.
I believe for question #2, that if a subpoena was issued it would be given to the superintendent of the school first, so that would take care of the need to call him/her. One of the questions that popped into my head as I was reading this chapter, was how often does this happen?
Great job!
Dixie
As librarians, we are not obligated to hand over any information regarding any materials checked out unless they have a court order even if it is a Federal Agent. I imagine it would be a bit scary and hard to not do it but we don't have to.
ReplyDelete4. I work in an elementary school, and if a student requests a book from the middle school or high school, then a selection slip has to be signed by a parent before the student can actually have the book.
ReplyDelete1. This is a hard one, and it kind of depends on the age level of the student. Elementary, I can see this happening. Though, I actually feel the parent should be having this discussion with their child as to what would be approriate for them to read. I have a hard time discouraging readers not to read something, because then that discourages reading as a whole. I would personally prefer (my opinion, not a librarians stand point) that if the student really truly wants to read a book the parent should take an active role and read the book too. Great discussions could happen here and the student is not pushed away from reading.
I think the rules of the school district would come into play here. In Lee's Summit, parents had authority over what their children read until they were 18 or were emancipated.
Delete3. Do you feel that online learning is less of an education than regular classroom learning or more?
ReplyDeleteI believe it depends on the individual student. I work well in a stimulating environment. I always enjoyed being in the classroom and I often learn best by seeing visuals and being able to interact with teachers. However, one of my brothers was distracted by the classroom environment and worked at a different pace than other students. His last couple years of high school he did a self-pace online program to finish his education and that worked so much better for him. He still went to school and sat at a computer, but he was able to take breaks whenever he needed them and he finished the courses at his own pace. I think it’s important to offer both kinds of instruction to accommodate all types of learners.
What a great example of why we need to have different ways of educating our students.
DeleteKatie
DeleteI love the fact that he was able to do his work at his own pace and still get the quality of education. I have A+LS in my library and I have several students who do their classwork on line as you described. It has made such a difference for them. Thanks for your reply!
2) If the law officer comes in and subpoena's your records of a teacher or student; do you quickly hand them over or do you call in your superintendent? Our chapter was confusing to me on this matter.
ReplyDeleteWow, that is a tough one! But I would have to say, "NO." I would not hand over any information about a student period. If they want the information they will have to go through the school's lawyers. I would hope that any federal official would follow protocol and not approach a librarian or classroom teacher for any informational about our students. When it comes to the safety of my students/children proceeding on the side of caution is always safest.
I too think that one should call in the superintendent and the school lawyers to handle this type of situation. Thanks for your reply
DeleteI have already taken a class last year that talked about issues such as book challenging. If I had a parent that requested that their child was to not read a certain book in the library, then I would have do as they ask. They are not asking me to take it off the shelf or is challenging the book, which really does not impend on the rights of other students. This may not be what we want to do, but if the child is under age I need to abide by their wishes. Of course, I would talk to the parent and ask questions and explain my selection process, but it is ultimately what the parent wants for their child.
ReplyDeleteThis was our policy at Lee's Summit as well.
DeleteI feel sorry for the child if a parent does this to them. This was a question that was placed before me and I am thankful for every ones help. I know that I must abide by their rules and that is so hard not to let someone read something.
DeleteNo, I don't feel online learning is less of an education than face to face learning. I think it sometimes requires different skills, though. As a strong auditory learner, I miss hearing discussions and explanations, but I have to adapt. However, that doesn't mean it is less of an education.
ReplyDeleteAwesome work and awesome questions! In regard to question three, I don't think that online learning is either less or more than in-classroom learning; I just think it's a different style of learning that some are more predisposed to than others. Personally I prefer online learning but I also recognize the importance of face-to-face interaction (I'm naturally a very introverted person, and I'm afraid that if I didn't make a concerted effort to maintain face-to-face interactions, that I would turn into some kind of a hermit). I think it's great that we've begun to shed a lot of the stigmas surrounding online learning, and I really love the idea of implementing it in areas that would not be conducive to in-classroom learning (as Catone suggests in our reading).
ReplyDeleteWe had district approved selection policy.
ReplyDeleteI should say we had a board approved selection policy.
DeleteThese are really good questions. I am going to share my thoughts on number 1. I do feel strongly about not allowing students to check out books, however, if I had a parent specifically ask that only their child not be able to check out certain books, I would abide by their wishes. If the challenged a book in general then I would refer to my school's selection policy, but I would not remove the book form the shelf unless the challenge resulted in that outcome.
ReplyDelete